Swinging and Investing Despite Overconfidence Bias

If you’re a bogey golfer, you’ve probably had your share of three putts (and sometimes four), but I’m willing to bet you haven’t experienced anything like what happened to Dustin Johnson at the 2015 U.S. Open.
southern pines financial advisor - Parsec Financial Planning - Fee Only Financial Advisor in Asheville NC Charlotte NC

That year Johnson found himself on 18th green trailing Jordan Spieth by one stroke with a 12-foot eagle putt to win.

Statistically speaking, Johnson had a 90% chance of making either the first or the second putt. If he made the first, he would win and net himself his first victory at a major. If he made the second, he would force a playoff with Spieth, and still be in the running.

He made neither.

Johnson would three putt and end up finishing tied for second.

That day on the 18th green, Dustin Johnson turned statistical probability on its head.

Playing the Odds

When it comes to numbers, our brains encounter some problems. They’re just not wired to comprehend probabilities. So, when we hear things like “90% chance” or “there’s a 1 in 500,000 chance of getting struck by lightning” our brains make a generalization about the probability of that event happening.

When we hear 90% chance, we think “that’s a sure thing.”

When we hear 1 in 500,000, we think “that will never happen to me.”

But in real life, that’s not how it works.

In the case of Dustin Johnson at the U.S. Open, he was going to miss both of those putts on 1 out of 10 occasions. It just so happens that 2015 was that one occasion.

Same thing applies to lightning strikes. Hundreds of people are actually struck by lightning every year.

This phenomena is called overconfidence bias, and it’s pervasive in all aspects of our lives, including investing.

Overconfidence Bias in Financial Markets

Market corrections, defined as a 10% decline from the most recent high, can be unnerving. Just think about how you felt last March when the S&P 500 was down more than 12%.

However, if I told you that the S&P 500 experiences a correction once every ten years, or only in 10% of years, you would probably feel pretty comfortable. Your sentiment would also be completely misguided because my statement is entirely false.

In fact, over the past two decades, the S&P 500 has experienced a correction in 11 years out of 20 years, or more than half. Market corrections are an extremely frequent event, and they will happen to you.

If you’re a mid-career professional, still saving for retirement, these pullbacks can be a great opportunity, because you have time on your side, but if you’re approaching or already in retirement, they can be quite nerve-racking.

What do you do?

Putting the Odds in your Favor

If you are a golfer, weather is out of your control and will undoubtedly play a large role in your experience on the course.

Likewise if you’re an investor. Volatility is out of your control and will undoubtedly play a large role in your experience in the markets.

Benjamin Graham, a much smarter investor than me, said, “The purpose of the margin of safety is to render the forecast unnecessary.”

To put it another way, if you pack your rain gear and your sunscreen then you don’t have to worry about the weatherman’s forecast next time you tee it up.

From an investment perspective, your margin of safety has a lot to do with your cash flow and time horizon. Here are a few things to consider before the next time you tee up a trade:

  • Your emergency fund is your sunscreen and rain gear. You won’t always need it, and that’s the point. It’s there for emergencies. Put it in your bag (or your savings account) and don’t touch it. You’ll be happy it’s there the next time you go for it.
  • Distance from your target matters. Big swings are great for drives; they’re not so great for putts. The closer you get to your target, the smaller your margin for error becomes. Decreasing volatility is important as you get closer to your goal.
  • Don’t imitate the pros. Whether it’s a swing tip you saw on social media or a trading strategy on TV, before you implement, evaluate it in the context of your own goals and objectives. What works for someone else might not always work for you.

Want more?
Here’s a short highlight reel from the 2015 U.S. Open where you can watch Dustin Johnson’s infamous three putt.

We just hosted our most heavily attended webinar about planning for uncertainty in the markets. You can check out a replay now.

Also, I often write about other investment topics as it relates to golf over at LinkedIn, which I invite you to check out.

Judson Meinhart, CFP®, BFATM, MBA
Financial Advisor, Manager of Financial Planning


Recent Posts:

How To Evaluate Taking on “Fun” Debt

Personally, there is nothing more relaxing and exhilarating than being on a sailboat with a 15-knot wind on your beam (side), listening to the soft sounds of water splashing against the bow and using wind energy to propel the boat forward.

Tax-Loss Harvesting Amidst Market Turmoil

Market declines like the one we are currently experiencing present great opportunities to take advantage of cheaper asset prices. Almost everyone with a taxable account should be harvesting tax losses during times like these.

“What If” Contingency Planning

We want to ensure you are thriving, as living a healthy and successful life is truly priceless. Of all the steps that can be taken toward financial security and peace of mind, planning our own death and incapacity is the least popular. Life goals dominate our consciousness, and these goals are often about ourselves. Estate planning is not as much about us as it is about the people and things that we love.

Recent Quarterly Newsletters:

Thrive By Ensuring Your Loved Ones Are OK Edition

Our Q3 2022 newsletter focuses on how to thrive by ensuring your loved ones are OK. In it, we have created an eight-page fillable guide you can create for loved ones to follow after you pass. We also provide other guidance on estate planning, caring for aging parents and preparing for a potential disability.

Thrive by Learning and Growing Edition

Read our Q2 2022 newsletter on how to thrive by learning and growing. CEO Rick Manske reflects on graduation season and what this time of achievement and change means for students and loved ones. CIO Bill Hansen writes about education savings; President Harli Palme writes about tax savings related to college expenses; Portfolio Manager Nancy Blackman cautions about hidden costs of college. Advisor Charles Thompson outlines why it’s important that we value and prioritize travel. Advisors Judd Meinhart and Hilary Daniel write about job transitions and what to do with your 401(k) and new benefits. Advisor Neal Nolan ends with 10 ways to celebrate Independence Day and we highlight announcements across our firm. We hope you enjoy this edition!

Recent Whitepapers:

Stay Up To Date With Parsec

Sign up to join our mailing list and receive quarterly newsletters, whitepapers, news, and more right in your inbox.
Scroll to Top

Not a Client But want to receive updates?

Please sign up to join our mailing list and receive our latest news, thought leadership content and invitations to upcoming webinars.